Eat This Book: Episode #14


“Give Us a King”

HOST: Michael Whitworth

GUEST: Chris Clevenger, author of “Sons of Dust” and host of the “Biblical Manliness” podcast.

The books of 1 and 2 Samuel have three primary characters: Samuel, Saul, and David. These books were originally one, but were divided in half by the Septuagint (LXX) translators. In the LXX, the books are known as 1 and 2 Kingdoms (1 and 2 Kings are known as 3 and 4 Kingdoms). Much of Samuel (as well as Kings) is repeated in Chronicles, but with one stark difference. Samuel does not dispute Saul’s right to rule Israel. Rather, the text goes to great lengths to show that Saul was God’s chosen one until Saul revolted against God’s sovereignty (e.g. 1 Sam. 13, 15). After the final episode involving the Amalekites, the kingdom was stripped away from Saul’s lineage (1 Sam. 15:28).


Given the fact that Samuel dies in 1 Samuel 25, it is considered highly unlikely that he wrote the entirety of these two books. In addition, 1 Chron. 29:29-30 indicates that Samuel’s work was part of a greater process contributed to by Nathan and Gad. Indeed, Jewish tradition in the Talmud attributed 1 Sam. 1-24 to Samuel, and the remainder to Nathan and Gad.

Date & Audience

As is the case with the other historical books, the author is technically anonymous, as is also the date of writing. However, we know that Samuel, Nathan, and Gad all ministered within fifty years on either side of 1000 BC. Regardless of the specific date of authorship, it can be reasonably assumed that these books were written to edify Israel and educate her of her history with God. The books of Samuel begin in a very dark period of Israel’s history, but light began to dawn with the ministry of Samuel and continued through the reign of David.

Samuel & the NT

Many parallels exist between David and Jesus. Both were seen as kings on the throne of Israel. Both (along with Saul) were considered “the Lord’s anointed” (1 Sam. 16:3, 6, 12-13; 24:6; 26:9, 11, 16, 23; 2 Sam. 1:14, 16; 3:39; 19:21), a phrase translated from the Hebrew messiah. But there also remain stark differences. David had a heart like God’s, but was not perfect. The shepherd boy who was willing to battle a lion and a bear (1 Sam. 17:34-35) was later willing for the sheep to die for his own sins (2 Sam. 24:14, 17), something that the Good Shepherd would never conceive of doing (John 10:11). He instead died for our sins.

Keys to Reading

  • While studying Samuel, one will notice several notes in the margin of one’s Bible giving an alternative reading to the text. The reason is that the Hebrew text is not as well-attested as other books. Problematic passages include 1 Sam. 11:1; 14:41; 2 Sam. 5:21 (cf. 1 Chron. 14:12). These verses in question do not pertain to our salvation, but they have puzzled scholars for quite some time. There is no clear way to resolve the difficulties they present.
  • Again, as is the case with the other historical books, the books of Samuel must be read with the message of Deuteronomy close at hand. Deuteronomy anticipated that Israel would one day have a king, but also warned of the terrible things that would come from the monarchy. Deuteronomy also promised that Israel would one day have rest from her enemies, and this certainly came true under the reign of David.
  • Conducting character-profile studies of Samuel, Saul, and David gives the Bible student greater insight into the stories of these two books. Samuel is presented as a much greater leader than Eli, though both men were not successful fathers. Likewise, Saul and David seem to have been just as morally-bankrupt as the other, but David is remembered as a man after God’s heart, while the Spirit of the Lord departed from Saul (1 Sam. 16:14).

**Discover other great resources like this article on our mobile app.**

eat this book

Subscribe & Get a FREE eBook

Sign-up to be notified of new posts and products from Start2Finish and get a FREE copy of the award-winning The Epic of God: A Guide to Genesis.


Michael Whitworth is the founder of Start2Finish and author of several books, including the award-winning "The Epic of God" and "The Derision of Heaven." In his spare time, Michael enjoys reading and drinking coffee, watching sports, and spending time with his awesome family and furry golden retriever.

1 Comment
  1. Reply
    Mary Kessinger November 15, 2016 at 5:43 pm

    I am back to listening to this podcast after several months of absence. I always learn a great deal and deeply appreciate this work.

    Killing several birds with this one reply, let me first comment on Samson. You asked why Samson’s life is so heavily covered. Have you considered that he is the only judge that we have record of, who was successful but perhaps trusted in his own strength rather than in God’s, then eventually humbled himself and allowed God to use him in a final mighty feat? It’s Samson’s change of heart that makes him stand out for me.

    Saul — I think that Saul showed no self-confidence, nor does he seem to have had confidence in God. Arrogance is often the other face of low self-esteem.

    David’s guilt — Vengenge is mine says the Lord, I will repay. I carried a huge amount of guilt over my weight problem. One of several things I recently figured out, was that I was not accepting God’s forgiveness and that I was taking it upon myself to punish myself for my mistakes. This makes me wonder if David was punishing himself instead of leaving it up to God?

Leave a reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.